Spotlight on WHO Historical Controversies

Mish

The World Health Organization has been involved in a number of controversies over the years. Let's take a look.

Given the WHO's praise of China and condemnation of other countries I thought it might be interesting to take a look historically at the WHO.

WHO Controversies

  1. West Nile Experiments: A field experiment in the West Nile district allowed researchers to take blood from children 3 times a day, in order to allegedly study an local disease causing mononucleosis. It has been alleged they were actually being infected with contaminated polio vaccines and their antibodies were being studied. Around 45,000 were tested from 1960-1973.
  2. Ebola and HIV Experimentation: It has been alleged that the WHO was aware of a Dr. Hilary Koprowski, a doctor allegedly performing research on AIDS and Ebola by deceiving and infecting Africans with a faux polio vaccine. It was estimated that over a million Africans were infected from 1954-1957. However, his work having been the cause of any disease has been refuted.
  3. 2013–2016 Ebola outbreak: Following the 2014 Ebola outbreak in West Africa, the organization was heavily criticized for its bureaucracy, insufficient financing, regional structure, and staffing profile.
  4. International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) controversies: The World Health Organization sub-department, the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), has been criticized for the way it analyses the tendency of certain substances and activities to cause cancer and for having a politically motivated bias when it selects studies for its analysis. Ed Yong, a British science journalist, has criticized the agency and its "confusing" category system for misleading the public. Marcel Kuntz, a French director of research at the French National Centre for Scientific Research, criticized the agency for its classification of potentially carcinogenic substances. He claimed that this classification did not take into account the extent of exposure: for example, red meat is qualified as probably carcinogenic, but the quantity of consumed red meat at which it could become dangerous is not specified.[147]
  5. IARC Cell Phones: Controversies have erupted multiple times when the IARC has classified many things as Class 2a (probable carcinogens) or 2b (possible carcinogen), including cell phone signals, glyphosate, drinking hot beverages, and working as a barber.
  6. Robert Mugabe's role as a goodwill ambassador: On 21 October 2017, the Director General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus appointed former Zimbabwean president Robert Mugabe as a WHO Goodwill Ambassador to help promote the fight against non-communicable diseases. The appointment address praised Mugabe for his commitment to public health in Zimbabwe. The appointment attracted widespread condemnation and criticism in WHO member states and international organizations due to Robert Mugabe's poor record on human rights and presiding over a decline in Zimbabwe's public health. Due to the outcry, the following day the appointment was revoked.

I compiled the above list from Wikipedia. There were more, but those looked like the most serious charges.

Looks Like a Pandemic

But hey, the WHO officials say it isn't.

Moreover, the WHO has praised China's strong quarantine approach and allegedly honest reporting while condemning the US and other countries for banning flights.

The WHO is a SPOS. The first "S" stands for sorry. You can work out the rest.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock

Comments (18)
No. 1-7
Carl_R
Carl_R

The WHO is no doubt idiotic, and their recommendation not to ban travel was exceptionally poor, but the CDC has done a fantastic job of quarantining people and preventing the spread in the US.

WarpartySerf
WarpartySerf

Just change the name to CCPWHO , and all is well and truthful.

Carl_R
Carl_R

Found this quote in an article on the Spanish Flu: “Truth and falsehood are arbitrary terms....The force of an idea lies in its inspirational value. It matters very little if it is true or false.” It is credited to an advisor to Woodrow Wilson, and led to the creation of the Committee on Public Information. The article goes on to the inevitable end of such a policy. "In most disasters, people come together, help each other... But in 1918... without the truth, trust evaporated. And people looked after only themselves."

abend237-04
abend237-04

Yes, but other than that one unfortunate incident, were you pleased with security at the theatre, Mrs. Lincoln?

njbr
njbr

34 year old doctor who first raised a warning about Corona virus dies of Cornavirus.

Are you young-uns still feeling good about the "old, feeble death demographic"?

njbr
njbr

...An additional 10 people aboard the now-quarantined Diamond Princess cruise liner have tested positive for the coronavirus, bringing the current total to 20....

If this spreads via same mechanism as norovirus (fecal/oral) and coughs and sneezes, this could be long-term trouble

njbr
njbr

By the way, with the cruise ship--and with any quarantine--do they let everyone go 14 days after the initiation of the quarantine or 14 days after the last case is revealed?

And if it is 14 days after the last case, what do you do about asymptomatic carriers (lung or intestinal)? How do you rule it out?

Call it the infinity cruise...with a 10 little Indians theme.


Global Economics

FEATURED
COMMUNITY