With Growth Sagging, China Shifts Back to Socialism
Benn Steil and Benjamin Della Rocca of the Council on Foreign Relations have spotted a recent change in China's strategy. From attempting to deleverage SOE, China has pivoted to "socialism or bust".
> “Deleveraging at State-Owned Enterprises,” said Chinese president Xi Jinping back in July 2017, “is of the utmost importance.”
> Fast forward to today, and the sentiment rings hollow. With growth under threat from an escalating trade war initiated by the Trump Administration, Xi has shifted his chips. China’s strategy is now “socialism or bust.”
> Instead of reducing SOE debt, the government has been boosting purchases from SOEs and stymieing private-sector competition to make that debt more manageable. The “focus is no longer on deleveraging,” explained Tsinghua University economist Zhu Ning, “but on transferring leverage from one sector to another”—that is, private to public.
> Whereas the People’s Bank of China has cut reserve requirements four times this year, large state-owned banks, which dominate deposit-taking, are channeling funds—as they always have—overwhelmingly to SOEs. Meanwhile, the government has clamped down on shadow-bank lending to private firms and forced many to close. The net result of a systematic shift in policy toward support for SOEs has been plummeting private-sector profitability. This in turn has, as shown in the bottom-right figure, increased nonperforming loans at rural banks, which lend primarily to private firms.
> China’s new strategy is buoying the economy in the short-term, but undermining it in the long-term. As shown in the top-right figure, return on assets in industrial firms is falling as business shifts to the less-productive state sector. This fact bodes badly for both future growth and debt levels.